antinomic

The two laws are antinomic and cannot be applied simultaneously.

Definition

Adjective: Describing something that is characterized by or involves an antinomy; that is, a contradiction between two apparently valid principles or conclusions that are each reasonable on their own but cannot both be true.

Usage Examples

• (The idea contains a logical contradiction between two equally plausible positions.)
• (Her beliefs were contradictory and self-opposing.)
• (Such statements reveal inherent inconsistencies.)

Advanced Usage

• "Antinomic relationship": a relationship between two ideas, principles, or forces that are in direct opposition yet both necessary.

  • The antinomic relationship between freedom and security is a central theme in political theory. (They are contradictory but interdependent.)

• "Antinomic structure": a logical or conceptual framework that contains a built-in contradiction.

  • The antinomic structure of the argument made it impossible to resolve. (The argument's internal contradiction prevented a clear conclusion.)

Variants and Related Words

• Antinomy (noun): a contradiction between two beliefs or conclusions that are each reasonable.

  • Kant's antinomies of pure reason explore conflicts between metaphysical ideas. (These are classic examples of logical contradictions.)

• Antinomical (adjective): an alternative form of "antinomic," meaning the same thing.

  • The antinomical nature of the proposal was evident to all experts. (The proposal was inherently contradictory.)

Synonyms

• Contradictory: expressing or implying the opposite.
• Paradoxical: seemingly absurd or self-contradictory but possibly true.
• Incongruous: not in harmony or keeping with the surroundings or other aspects.

Related Idioms

• A house divided against itself: a situation in which internal contradictions cause conflict or failure.

  • The antinomic policies of the organization made it a house divided against itself. (The contradictory rules weakened the group.)

• Caught between a rock and a hard place: faced with two equally undesirable or contradictory options.

  • The antinomic demands of his job and his family left him caught between a rock and a hard place. (He faced irreconcilable pressures.)