instrumentalism

/,instru'mentəlizm/
Học thuật
Thân thiện
Definition
  1. Noun:
    • A system of pragmatic philosophy: Instrumentalism is a philosophical theory within pragmatism. It views ideas, theories, and concepts not as true or false representations of reality, but as instruments or tools for problem-solving, prediction, and guiding action.
    • A theory of knowledge and meaning: It holds that the value and meaning of an idea are determined by its practical success and usefulness in achieving desired outcomes, rather than by its correspondence to an objective truth.
Examples of Usage
  • Noun:
    • John Dewey's philosophy is often described as a form of instrumentalism.
    • According to instrumentalism, a scientific theory is a useful instrument for making predictions, not a literal description of the world.
    • The debate between realism and instrumentalism centers on whether theories aim to describe reality or are merely tools.
Advanced Usage
  • Methodological Instrumentalism: A view, often in the philosophy of science, that treats theoretical entities (like electrons or genes) as useful fictions for organizing data and making predictions, without making claims about their actual existence.
    • Some philosophers of science adopt a methodological instrumentalism regarding unobservable entities.
  • As a critical term: The term can be used critically to describe an approach deemed overly focused on practical results at the expense of truth or principle.
    • His policy was criticized for its crude instrumentalism, treating every relationship as a transaction.
Variants and Related Words
  • Instrumentalist (noun): A person who advocates or adheres to instrumentalism.
    • Dewey was a leading instrumentalist of the 20th century.
  • Instrumental (adjective): Pertaining to instruments or means; serving as a means to an end. (Note: This is the general adjective, not the philosophical doctrine).
    • Technology is instrumental in modern research.
Synonyms
  • Pragmatism (in a specific, technical sense): Instrumentalism is a major strand within the broader philosophical tradition of pragmatism.
  • Operationalism: A related view emphasizing that concepts are defined by the operations used to measure or apply them.
  • Tool Theory of Mind: A less common, descriptive synonym highlighting the core metaphor.
Related Phrases
  • Instrumental value: The value something has as a means to achieve something else, in contrast to intrinsic value. This phrase is directly related to the core idea of instrumentalism.
    • For an instrumentalist, knowledge has primarily instrumental value.
  • Instrumental reasoning: Reasoning focused on identifying the most effective means to achieve a given end.
    • The decision was based purely on instrumental reasoning.
Related Concepts/Ideas
  • Pragmatism: The broader philosophical movement from which instrumentalism derives, associated with Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, and John Dewey.
  • Scientific Anti-Realism: Instrumentalism is a form of anti-realism regarding scientific theories, contrasting with scientific realism.
  • Utilitarianism: While distinct, both philosophies emphasize practical consequences and usefulness, though utilitarianism is an ethical theory and instrumentalism is epistemological.
Noun
  1. a system of pragmatic philosophy that considers idea to be instruments that should guide our actions and their value is measured by their success